Unique Baby Gifts Every Mom Will Love

Most new moms rely on registries for all the items they want and need, but what happens when the list is all purchased? Or out of your budget? Or, maybe you just want to give a unique baby gift that has more meaning or reasoning behind it. More than likely, all the essentials will be bought, so it’s always nice to consider new baby gifts that are more personal or sentimental. And nowadays, they’re pretty easy to find. A quick search can help you discover some of the cutest online baby boutiques or one of a kind Etsy baby gifts you can give, like an adorable personalized teether, the most popular pregnancy books or even organic faith-based clothing items. Whether you’re shopping for baptism gifts or the best baby shower presents, we believe it’s almost always better to give something special, not ordinary.

 We’ve put together a list of some of our favorite little shops to give you the latest and greatest in baby shower gift ideas, all hand-crafted, all made in the USA, and all adorable. 

 Beautiful Baby Bonnets


One gift you might not think about are the extra accessories a mom might not want to spend the money on but would love to have! briarhandmade.com offers made in USA, Organic Cotton handmade bonnets that make for the perfect add-on to any outfit. If you follow them on social media, you can get great ideas to put together a great gift set for the little one in your life. Speaking of social media, you know moms love to show off their precious babies in their cutest outfits and accessories, and one of these handmade baby bonnets will make their photo evens even better, because they look adorable on any precious baby. 

Organic Star Doll Cuddle Toy

Wild Creek

It can be hard to decide on what to buy for that upcoming shower. Maybe you just want one a little add-on to your registry purchase to make your gift stand out. An organic cotton cuddle toy can make for the perfect newborn baby gift, giving the child a toy that they can grow with. And if it’s special and unique enough, it might just be the one toy they always want by their side. Check out wildcreek.co for some of the best bunnies and cutest stuffed toys we’ve seen – some are perfect for those sore gums.  

Hand-Made Hooded Towels

Sew Me Shoppe

Some babies love bath time, and as they grow, they can have so much fun splashing around and making their time in the tub fun. But an even better way to make it more rewarding is a special towel they’ll love, one that can get their imaginations soaring and give moms a great photo opp. These hooded towels from SewMeShoppe are great for a personalized baby gift, and with many animals to choose from, you can’t go wrong choosing one as a great gift idea for babies.

 Faith-Based Baby Clothing

Mustard Seed Baby

 There are so many baby clothes out there, but huge companies often don’t care about the details. At Mustard Seed Baby, that’s one of the most important things we care about. We strive to provide the highest quality, which means all GOTS Organic Cotton, in anything we create. We care about our customers and the babies who wear our products. 

We also care about positive messaging from day one and sharing Christ’s love through the items we make. Our unique line offers inspirational and faith-based baby clothes, blankets and bibs.  Our mission is to give moms items they’re proud to put on their kids and we believe we have some of the best baby shower presents for your little one!  Share our pride in knowing that with every purchase made, together we help support kids in foster care.

Personalized Baby Teether

High Teething Company

You can spend hours searching Etsy baby gifts, for pacifier clips you can buy, but none of them are quite like these. The quality and craft that goes into each of Mile High Teething Company’s pacifier clips and teething rings is incredible – and we’re big fans. With nice, neutral colors and pretty beading, there are awesome options to choose from, and even the ability to have the baby’s name put on the item. Moms love personalized baby gifts! And it shows you really spent the time to put some thought into your gift, which goes a long way.